407 Bay Street

Orillia, Ontario L3V 3X5

Overview

At a glance

Days on market355 days
ListedNov 6, 2025
UpdatedOct 26, 2026
Building age51-99 years
Size2000-2500 sq ft
Lot82.98 x 214 Feet
Property taxes$9,887 (2025)
Parking6 spaces
BasementApartment, Finished with Walk-Out, Full
MLS® numberS12515842
Data sourcePropTx MLS® System
Listing brokerageRE/MAX RIGHT MOVE

About this home

Welcome to 407 Bay Street, Orillia - located in one of the city's most desirable neighbourhoods. This stunning custom-built 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath, two-storey home showcases exceptional craftsmanship, modern design, and high-end finishes throughout. The main level offers an open-concept dining area and a gorgeous farmhouse-style kitchen featuring a custom oak island, quartz countertops, floating shelves, and a pot filler. The living room boasts a beautiful brick accent wall and a gas fireplace, complemented by an office, 2-piece bath, and a spacious laundry/mudroom with garage access and a walkout to the rear deck. Upstairs, you'll find three bedrooms, including a bright primary suite with a 3-piece ensuite, plus an additional 4-piece bath. The fully finished lower level features a large recreation room with a gas fireplace, wet bar/kitchenette, walkout to the backyard, two additional bedrooms, a 3-piece bath, fitness area, utility room, and storage. (In-law suite with walk out to pool). The backyard is perfect for family enjoyment, backing onto scenic recreational trails and featuring an in-ground pool with a newer liner and concrete surround. This home has been extensively updated with premium finishes - custom millwork, built-in cabinetry, ship lap details, cedar accents, stunning tile work, upgraded fixtures, and elegant brass hardware. Additional updates include a metal roof, new main and second level windows, composite decking, Regal railing and more. Located across the street from Lake Couchiching, water access via an unopened 66' Bay Street road allowance or Borland St, just minutes to downtown, Couchiching Beach Park, boat launch, shopping and more. A truly remarkable home that must be seen in person to be appreciated.

Details

Property

Style
2-Storey
Building age
51-99
Fronting on
West
Cross street
Fittons & Bay
Community
Orillia
Municipality
Orillia

Inside

Bedrooms above grade
3
Bedrooms below grade
2
Bathrooms
4
Kitchens
2
Basement
Apartment, Finished with Walk-Out, Full
Family room
Yes
Fireplace
Fireplace Insert, Natural Gas
Interior features
Auto Garage Door Remote, Countertop Range

Utilities

Heating
Forced Air
Heating fuel
Gas
Cooling
Central Air
Sewer
Sewer
Electricity
Yes
Cable
Yes

Building

Construction
Brick, Vinyl Siding
Foundation
Concrete Block
Roof
Metal
Pool
Inground

Parking

Garage
Attached
Parking spaces
6
Total parking
6
Driveway
Private Double, Circular Drive

Land

Frontage
82.98
Depth
214
Lot size units
Feet
Lot irregularities
irr
Waterfront
No
Topography
Sloping, Level
Property features
Beach, Fenced Yard, Golf, Hospital, Park, Public Transit
Rooms (17)
RoomLevelSizeFeatures
KitchenMain5.08 x 4.31
Dining RoomMain5.08 x 4.31
Living RoomMain4.16 x 5.03
LaundryMain3.74 x 3.49
OfficeMain1.82 x 2.4
FoyerMain5.18 x 4.69
BathroomMain2.28 x 1.33
Primary BedroomSecond3.91 x 4.25
BathroomSecond4.24 x 2.264 Pc Ensuite
Bedroom 2Second3.18 x 4.27
Bedroom 3Second4.97 x 3.01
BathroomSecond3.18 x 1.634 Pc Bath
RecreationBasement9.46 x 5.05
BedroomBasement3.91 x 3.86
BedroomBasement3.76 x 4.45
BathroomBasement3.33 x 2.13
KitchenBasement3 x 1B/I Bar
Value

What it’s worth

Automated estimate

Free Sold Nearby account

What this home is likely to sell for, based on its asking price and what similar homes nearby have actually sold for.

Create a free account

Market read

Free Sold Nearby account

Whether Orillia is a buyer’s or seller’s market right now, and how long homes like this usually take to sell.

Create a free account

History

Listing history

Past listings and sales

Free Sold Nearby account

When this home was listed before, every price change, and what it sold for last time.

Create a free account

Compare

How it compares

Sold comparables

Free Sold Nearby account

The recent sales nearby most like this home, and what each one sold for.

Create a free account

Neighbourhood

Around Orillia

What’s nearby

Backs onto a trailQuiet streetBackyard faces west

  • Elementary schoolCouchiching Heights Public Schoolabout 10 min walk
  • High schoolPatrick Fogarty Secondary Schoolabout 18 min walk
  • ParkCouchiching Beach Parkabout 13 min walk
  • Playground about 14 min walk
  • TrailLightfoot Trailabout 1 min walk
  • River or lakeLake Couchichingabout 1 min walk
  • Grocery storeFoodlandabout 10 min walk
  • DowntownOrilliaabout 28 min walk
  • LibraryOrillia Public Libraryabout 30 min walk
  • Rec centre or arenaThe Lighthouseabout 35 min walk
  • Golf courseCouchiching Golf & Country Clubabout 12 min walk
  • HospitalOrillia Soldiers' Memorial Hospitalabout 2.5 km
  • Highway on-rampExit 135about 21 min walk
  • GO or train stationWashagoabout 15 km

Approximate: straight-line distances, and the backyard and street worked out from the map pin and map data © OpenStreetMap contributors. Check school boundaries with the school board.

On the map

Sold nearby

Free Sold Nearby account

Homes within 3 km that sold in the last year, what they sold for and how fast.

Create a free account

Community

The Orillia market

Orillia sale prices

Free Sold Nearby account

The median sale price in Orillia month by month, how fast homes sell, and how close they come to asking.

Create a free account

Costs

What it would cost

%
%
An example rate. Use the one your lender quotes.
Every monthEstimate
Mortgage payment$0
Property tax$0
Monthly total$0
At closing
Ontario land transfer tax$0

Estimates only, not financial advice. Uses Canadian semi-annual compounding, the minimum down payment and mortgage insurance rules, and Ontario’s land transfer tax brackets. Your lender and lawyer confirm the real numbers. Legal fees, title insurance and moving costs aren’t included.

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX RIGHT MOVE. Listing information from the PropTx MLS® System. Each listing shows the brokerage that represents it. The information provided herein must only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial purpose or any other purpose. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by PropTx. Last updated October 27, 2026 at 6:41 p.m.

See this home with Kris.

No obligation. Kris replies personally. Privacy policy

Your request goes to Kris Butler, Salesperson, M1 Real Estate Brokerage Ltd. He isn’t the listing agent for this home.

Selling nearby?

Get a valuation built from sales like this one, and see what you’d save with a 1% listing fee.

See what you’d save →
What’s my home worth?