5096 Island 865 N/A

Baxter, Georgian Bay, Ontario L0K 1S0

Overview

At a glance

Days on market508 days
ListedJun 6, 2025
UpdatedAug 7, 2026
Building age51-99 years
Size< 700 sq ft
Lot138 x 193.05 Feet
Property taxes$1,956 (2024)
Parking0 spaces
BasementNone
MLS® numberX12201351
Data sourcePropTx MLS® System
Listing brokerageSotheby's International Realty Canada

About this home

Welcome to your dream escape just 1 hour and 40 minutes from the GTA and a quick 2-minute boat ride from the marina. This well-maintained, boat-access cottage is set on a private and picturesque 0.674-acre lot with 138 feet of pristine waterfront on a quiet bay, offering the perfect blend of tranquility, comfort, and adventure. The charming 2-bedroom cottage features a bright and airy open-concept layout, enhanced by vaulted ceilings and tasteful décor throughout. The living room is warmed by a fireplace with airtight insert, and the kitchen with dining area is ideal for gathering with family and friends. Laminate flooring in the kitchen and living room adds to the cottages clean, updated feel, while a 3-piece bathroom ensures all the essentials are covered. Step outside to a spacious deck that overlooks the sparkling water, ideal for morning coffee, afternoon lounging, or evening cocktails with a sunset view. A large dock with deep water offers excellent swimming and boating access, while a sandy beach area along the shore is perfect for children and pets to play. As the sun sets, gather around the fire pit overlooking the bay and soak in the serene views and golden light dancing on the water. An 8' x 12' Bunkie adds extra accommodation space for guests, making this property a wonderful option for hosting weekend getaways or summer holidays. Whether you're looking for a peaceful place to recharge or a lakeside hub for fun-filled days on the water, this turnkey property delivers an unforgettable cottage experience. Accessible, inviting, and fully ready for the season, this is your opportunity to own a slice of waterfront paradise.

Details

Property

Style
Bungalow
Building age
51-99
Fronting on
North
Cross street
Highway 400 and South Bay Road
Community
Baxter
Municipality
Georgian Bay

Inside

Bedrooms above grade
2
Bathrooms
1
Kitchens
1
Basement
None
Family room
No
Fireplace
Fireplace Insert, Wood
Interior features
Water Heater Owned

Utilities

Heating
Other
Heating fuel
Wood
Cooling
None
Water
Lake/River
Sewer
Holding Tank
Electricity
Yes
Cable
No

Building

Construction
Wood
Foundation
Block, Piers
Roof
Metal
Exterior features
Deck
Pool
None

Parking

Garage
None
Parking spaces
0
Total parking
0
Driveway
None

Land

Frontage
138
Depth
193.05
Lot size units
Feet
Lot size (acres)
.50-1.99
Waterfront
Dock, Marine Rail, Stairs to Waterfront, Beach Front
Topography
Rocky, Rolling, Wooded/Treed, Partially Cleared, Sloping
Property features
Lake/Pond, Wooded/Treed, Sloping, Marina
Rooms (6)
RoomLevelSizeFeatures
Living RoomMain5.359 x 3.51Fireplace Insert, Laminate, Vaulted Ceiling(s)
KitchenMain5.359 x 2.31Laminate, Vaulted Ceiling(s)
BedroomMain2.845 x 2.565Vaulted Ceiling(s), Laminate
Bedroom 2Main2.845 x 2.718Vaulted Ceiling(s), Laminate
BathroomMain1.956 x 1.933 Pc Bath, Ceramic Floor
FoyerMain1.956 x 0.787Laminate, Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Value

What it’s worth

Automated estimate

Free Sold Nearby account

What this home is likely to sell for, based on its asking price and what similar homes nearby have actually sold for.

Create a free account

Market read

Free Sold Nearby account

Whether Baxter is a buyer’s or seller’s market right now, and how long homes like this usually take to sell.

Create a free account

History

Listing history

Past listings and sales

Free Sold Nearby account

When this home was listed before, every price change, and what it sold for last time.

Create a free account

Compare

How it compares

Sold comparables

Free Sold Nearby account

The recent sales nearby most like this home, and what each one sold for.

Create a free account

Neighbourhood

Around Baxter

On the map

The pin is on the right street, but this address couldn’t be placed exactly.

Sold nearby

Free Sold Nearby account

Homes within 3 km that sold in the last year, what they sold for and how fast.

Create a free account

Community

The Baxter market

Baxter sale prices

Free Sold Nearby account

The median sale price in Baxter month by month, how fast homes sell, and how close they come to asking.

Create a free account

Costs

What it would cost

%
%
An example rate. Use the one your lender quotes.
Every monthEstimate
Mortgage payment$0
Property tax$0
Monthly total$0
At closing
Ontario land transfer tax$0

Estimates only, not financial advice. Uses Canadian semi-annual compounding, the minimum down payment and mortgage insurance rules, and Ontario’s land transfer tax brackets. Your lender and lawyer confirm the real numbers. Legal fees, title insurance and moving costs aren’t included.

Listing courtesy of Sotheby's International Realty Canada. Listing information from the PropTx MLS® System. Each listing shows the brokerage that represents it. The information provided herein must only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial purpose or any other purpose. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by PropTx. Last updated October 27, 2026 at 9:00 p.m.

See this home with Kris.

No obligation. Kris replies personally. Privacy policy

Your request goes to Kris Butler, Salesperson, M1 Real Estate Brokerage Ltd. He isn’t the listing agent for this home.

Selling nearby?

Get a valuation built from sales like this one, and see what you’d save with a 1% listing fee.

See what you’d save →
What’s my home worth?