2877 McSherry Lane

559 - Cataract Road, Thorold, Ontario L0S 1E6

Overview

At a glance

Days on market136 days
ListedJun 12, 2026
UpdatedAug 19, 2026
Building age6-15 years
Size3500-5000 sq ft
Lot313.17 x 547.85 Feet
Property taxes$14,332 (2026)
Parking14 spaces
BasementFull, Separate Entrance, Apartment, Walk-Out
MLS® numberX13438342
Data sourcePropTx MLS® System
Listing brokerageSOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY CANADA

About this home

A rare offering that combines the timeless charm of a classic farmhouse with the comfort and efficiency of modern construction. Built in 2010 and set on over 5 picturesque acres surrounded by mature trees, this exceptional property offers a peaceful country setting just minutes from all the amenities of Fonthill. From the moment you arrive, the home's authentic farmhouse-inspired architecture, handsome brick exterior, and expansive front porch create a lasting impression. Thoughtfully designed and crafted using quality local materials, the home is rich in character while offering the conveniences expected by today's discerning buyer. At the heart of the home is a stunning custom kitchen featuring soaring 14-foot ceilings, exceptional millwork, and an inviting open-concept design that naturally draws family and friends together. The space is both grand and welcoming, perfectly suited for everyday living and entertaining alike. The main floor offers the convenience of a spacious primary bedroom, allowing for comfortable one-level living. Upstairs, two additional bedrooms are complemented by a versatile bonus room currently used as a sitting room/den, ideal as a home office, library, or potential fourth bedroom. A truly unique feature is the fully self-contained lower-level in-law suite with its own private entrance, providing outstanding flexibility for multi-generational living, extended family, guests, or income potential. Surrounded by nature and offering exceptional privacy, this beautiful property delivers the best of both worlds-tranquil country living with shops, restaurants, schools, golf, and everyday conveniences only minutes away. A distinctive home where craftsmanship, character, and lifestyle come together in a truly remarkable setting.

Details

Property

Style
2-Storey
Building age
6-15
Fronting on
South
Cross street
Hwy 406 & Hwy 20
Community
559 - Cataract Road
Municipality
Thorold

Inside

Bedrooms above grade
3
Bedrooms below grade
1
Bathrooms
3
Kitchens
2
Basement
Full, Separate Entrance, Apartment, Walk-Out
Family room
Yes
Fireplace
Wood
Interior features
In-Law Suite, Water Softener, Water Purifier

Utilities

Heating
Forced Air
Heating fuel
Propane
Cooling
Central Air
Water
Drilled Well
Sewer
Septic

Building

Construction
Brick Front
Foundation
Poured Concrete
Roof
Cedar
Pool
None

Parking

Garage
None
Parking spaces
0
Total parking
14
Driveway
Private

Land

Frontage
313.17
Depth
547.85
Lot size units
Feet
Lot size (acres)
5-9.99
Waterfront
No
Topography
Flat, Partially Cleared, Wooded/Treed
Property features
Wooded/Treed, Cul de Sac/Dead End
Rooms (11)
RoomLevelSizeFeatures
KitchenMain6.39 x 5.48Combined w/Dining, Combined w/Great Rm
Living RoomMain8.23 x 4.24
Primary BedroomMain5.57 x 4.17
LaundryMain2.65 x 2.15
BedroomSecond4.42 x 2.94
BedroomSecond4.42 x 3.33
Family RoomSecond4.16 x 4.05
KitchenLower7.41 x 4.49Combined w/Living
BedroomLower4.5 x 4.42
RecreationLower7.57 x 5.99
LaundryLower3.24 x 2.71
Value

What it’s worth

Automated estimate

Free Sold Nearby account

What this home is likely to sell for, based on its asking price and what similar homes nearby have actually sold for.

Create a free account

Market read

Free Sold Nearby account

Whether 559 - Cataract Road is a buyer’s or seller’s market right now, and how long homes like this usually take to sell.

Create a free account

History

Listing history

Past listings and sales

Free Sold Nearby account

When this home was listed before, every price change, and what it sold for last time.

Create a free account

Compare

How it compares

Sold comparables

Free Sold Nearby account

The recent sales nearby most like this home, and what each one sold for.

Create a free account

Neighbourhood

Around 559 - Cataract Road

What’s nearby

Quiet streetBackyard faces south

  • Elementary schoolSt. Alexander Catholic Elementary Schoolabout 31 min walk
  • High schoolE. L. Crossley Secondary Schoolabout 4.7 km
  • ParkSt. John's Conservation Areaabout 14 min walk
  • Playground about 20 min walk
  • Trail about 11 min walk
  • River or lakeTwelve Mile Creekabout 7 min walk
  • Grocery storeFood Basicsabout 26 min walk
  • DowntownFonthillabout 35 min walk
  • LibraryPelham Public Library - Fonthill Branchabout 35 min walk
  • Rec centre or arenaMerrittville Speedwayabout 28 min walk
  • Golf courseLookout Point Country Clubabout 2.7 km
  • HospitalHotel Dieu Shaver Health and Rehabilitation Centreabout 6.9 km
  • Highway on-ramp about 2.6 km
  • GO or train stationSt. Catharinesabout 9.4 km

Approximate: straight-line distances, and the backyard and street worked out from the map pin and map data © OpenStreetMap contributors. Check school boundaries with the school board.

On the map

Sold nearby

Free Sold Nearby account

Homes within 3 km that sold in the last year, what they sold for and how fast.

Create a free account

Community

The 559 - Cataract Road market

559 - Cataract Road sale prices

Free Sold Nearby account

The median sale price in 559 - Cataract Road month by month, how fast homes sell, and how close they come to asking.

Create a free account

Costs

What it would cost

%
%
An example rate. Use the one your lender quotes.
Every monthEstimate
Mortgage payment$0
Property tax$0
Monthly total$0
At closing
Ontario land transfer tax$0

Estimates only, not financial advice. Uses Canadian semi-annual compounding, the minimum down payment and mortgage insurance rules, and Ontario’s land transfer tax brackets. Your lender and lawyer confirm the real numbers. Legal fees, title insurance and moving costs aren’t included.

Listing courtesy of SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY CANADA. Listing information from the PropTx MLS® System. Each listing shows the brokerage that represents it. The information provided herein must only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial purpose or any other purpose. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by PropTx. Last updated October 26, 2026 at 2:52 p.m.

See this home with Kris.

No obligation. Kris replies personally. Privacy policy

Your request goes to Kris Butler, Salesperson, M1 Real Estate Brokerage Ltd. He isn’t the listing agent for this home.

Selling nearby?

Get a valuation built from sales like this one, and see what you’d save with a 1% listing fee.

See what you’d save →
What’s my home worth?